All the designs raise different questions for me; what atmosphere each screen demands? Where would it be placed, what colour gives the best needed emphasis, what lighting does it require? I started to think that patterns itself can not answer these question without the environment. However, now I understand design as a balance of compromise if the context around is not given. Perhaps the one which is the most balanced in terms of its suitability for each space should be the winner. Or maybe when the balance of attention, interest and atmospheric fitness is kept, the space and design just become one solid mass without sharpness and excitement?
Another question is would the patterns remain the same after being done from its actual material?
Questions and ponderings above are just my personal observations, and I would really like to know how others would describe the winner. So please feel free to comment :)